Why is 50% the Limit for Particle Counting Efficiency Sizing Thresholds?

Why is 50% the Limit for Particle Counting Efficiency Sizing Thresholds?

Particle counting efficiency is crucial in particle measurement, especially when using optical particle counters. This term denotes the likelihood of precisely detecting and enumerating particles within a specified size spectrum. In this context, the term “particle counting efficiency” represents the ability of the particle counter to quantify particles of a given size accurately. It measures the instrument’s performance, indicating how effectively it can detect and count particles of various sizes.

The significance of particle counting efficiency lies in its direct impact on the reliability and accuracy of particle measurement. For instance, in applications such as air quality monitoring, pharmaceutical manufacturing, or research in aerosol science, the precision in measuring particle size and concentration is paramount. A higher counting efficiency means the counter is more effective in detecting and counting the particles within its designated size range, leading to more accurate and reliable data.particle counting efficiency

When discussing the “limit for counting efficiency sizing thresholds” for optical particle counters, the 50% threshold is a standard benchmark. Of course, a 100% counting efficiency test is performed at a size greater than the first threshold, as mandated in ISO 21501-4. This makes sense for overall optical efficiency. However, our article will focus on why 50% is chosen as the limit for counting efficiency sizing thresholds in optical particle counters. That way, you can apply it in a variety of situations. This includes cleanroom particle counting as an air quality monitoring solution.

The Principle of Particle Counting Efficiency

Particle counting efficiency in optical particle counters is defined as the likelihood of the device detecting and accurately counting a particle as it traverses the sample volume of the counter. It signifies the percentage of particles counted at or above a specified size. 

The probability is crucial in ensuring the precision and reliability of particle counting, particularly in environments where particle size distribution is a critical parameter. This includes cleanroom monitoring and various industrial processes, as continuous monitoring is required to measure particles and confirm that clean air is present. 

The Imperative of the 50% Threshold

The 50% particle counting efficiency sizing threshold represents the balancing point in an optical particle counter’s ability to detect particles at its most sensitive size limit. Real-world optical particle counters exhibit a range of resolutions that impact their efficiency curves. Unlike hypothetical optical particle counters with perfect resolution, real-world devices show an asymmetrical efficiency curve. This is because of the exponential relationship between particle size and the signal produced.

  • Consistency in Sensitivity: Selecting the 50% level of particle counting efficiency for the most sensitive threshold ensures uniformity across different resolution optical particle counters. This standardization is essential for meaningful comparisons of optical particle counter data with reference standards and other particle counters.
  • Minimizing Resolution Dependence: By adopting the 50% threshold, the impact of variations in sensor resolution on the determination of the most sensitive threshold is minimized. This approach avoids the displacement of the nominal threshold that would occur with different levels of counting efficiency. Ultimately, this can ensure more accurate and consistent particle sizing.
  • Harmonization with Calibration Standards: The 50% threshold aligns with industry-standard calibration procedures. This threshold is especially significant in the context of ‘half-count’ calibration. 

The half-count calibration process involves particles with a narrow size distribution matching closely with the sizing threshold of the optical particle counters. By using this calibrated standard, optical particle counters will provide consistent and comparable results.

  • Impact on Real-World Particle Distributions: In actual particle distributions, the optical particle counter’s counting efficiency influences the accuracy of particle size measurements. These are broader than monodispersed particle distributions. 50% counting efficiency sizing thresholds allow for a more accurate representation of these distributions. This includes situations where particle concentration increases rapidly as particle size decreases.
Optical Particle Counters Need 50% Counting Efficiency Sizing Thresholds To Produce Excellent Results

The 50% particle counting efficiency sizing threshold in optical particle counters can enhance the accuracy, consistency, and reliability of light scattered particle size measurements. By using the threshold, measurements can: 

  • Address the inherent limitations of real-world optical particle counters
  • Ensure comparability with reference standards 
  • Adapt to the diverse nature of particle distributions encountered in various industrial and scientific applications.

In summary, the 50% particle counting efficiency sizing threshold in optical particle counters is a critical parameter that balances the need for accuracy and consistency in particle sizing. Counting efficiency sizing thresholds ensure reliable data across a wide range of applications, such as for environmental monitoring systems, as well as cleanroom particle counters and handheld particle counters. 

For more information on environmental monitoring systems, or other related topics, such as ISO 14644-1, viable particles or the effect of flow rates, please contact the experts at Particle Measuring Systems. They would be happy to help you find the real-time measurement system that would best suit your project. 

Contact us

Explore Other Topics

Search Knowledge Center: