Optimizing Microbial Sampling Methods in Pharma Manufacturing
Microbial air samplers in pharmaceutical manufacturing facilities can be used via several methods:
- surface microbial sampling
- passive air microbial environmental sampling
- active air microbial environmental sampling
Each of these microbial air sampling methods produces a result based on the growth of microbial colonies on the surface of a collection media (typically agar), but the specific instruments and techniques vary between the methods.
The results from any individual element of sampling do not constitute evidence of asepsis, so all elements of sampling should be used collectively in support of sterility assurance, as is given in the current version of EU GMP Annex 1: 2022 (Learn more about Annex 1: 2022 here)
9.1 The site’s environmental and process monitoring programme forms part of the overall CCS and is used to monitor the controls designed to minimize the risk of microbial and particle contamination. It should be noted that the reliability of each of the elements of the monitoring system (viable, nonviable and APS) when taken in isolation is limited and should not be considered individually to be an indicator of asepsis. When considered together, the results help confirm the reliability of the design, validation, and operation of the system that they are monitoring.
More specific regulations and the elements of surface microbial air monitoring and passive microbial air monitoring (settle plates) are discussed elsewhere in the regulation document. For all the microbial air sampling methods, it is important to be sure that the sample accurately reflects the environmental microbiological condition. This is often measured and discussed in terms of collection efficiency. The focus of this paper will mainly be on active microbial air sampling, but there are sampling characteristics for each type of sampling that ensure the optimized collection efficiency.
Environmental Monitoring to determine sterility assurance is a multifaceted exercise, and reliance on a single element is understood to be inconclusive. Microbial sampling is a function of environmental monitoring, and within critical, high-risk, Grade A environments, the ability to accurately differentiate a zero count (0) from a single count (1) requires empirical quantitative data due to the reality that sterility cannot be determined as zero is a virtual concept; all of the air in all of the areas cannot be tested. No single data point can determine the contamination at high confidence, and this has led EU Annex 1 to implement a requirement for continuous microbial sampling with the Grade A areas.
To extend the sample periods, the application of settle plates can be considered, but these are qualitative (or, at best, semi-quantitative), and not the most suitable technique when differentiating the zeros and ones. Read this paper to learn more…